Job Offer Comparison Calculator
Compare two job offers side by side using salary, benefits, commute, and other factors to find the better deal.
Did this tool work for you?
How to use this calculator
Net compensation subtracts annual commute costs from total pay. True compensation further deducts the monetary value of time spent commuting (commute hours × effective hourly rate). A scoring system adds weighted PTO and remote work values for a holistic comparison.
- 1
Enter salary, bonus, annual commute cost, and daily commute time for both Offer A and Offer B.
- 2
Add PTO days and remote work days per week — these are converted into a monetary equivalent for fair comparison.
- 3
Review the true compensation figures and the recommendation to see which offer delivers more total value.
Frequently asked questions
What formulas does the tool use?
Net compensation = salary + bonus − annual commute cost. Hourly equivalent = salary ÷ 2,080. Annual commute hours = daily round-trip hours × 235 × (5 − remote days) ÷ 5, and the commute time value is those hours × the hourly equivalent. True compensation = net compensation − commute time value. The recommendation then uses a weighted value: true compensation + $50 per PTO day + $500 per remote day a week.
Why are PTO and remote days not in the true compensation lines?
The true compensation lines only reflect money and commute time. PTO and remote days are added afterwards, at a fixed $50 per PTO day and $500 per remote day per week, to give the weighted value that decides the recommendation. The results panel shows the weighted values so you can see exactly why one offer wins.
How do remote days affect the commute?
The 235 working days a year are scaled by the share of the week spent in the office, so 3 remote days leaves two-fifths of the commuting. Entering 5 removes the commute time value entirely. The annual commute cost is used exactly as typed, so lower it yourself if remote days reduce your fuel or fare spending.
Which salary figure is used to value commute time?
The base salary divided by 2,080 hours, which is 40 hours × 52 weeks. Bonus is not included in the hourly value. A salary of $70,000 gives $33.65 an hour, and a one-hour round trip over 235 days values at $7,908.65.
What happens when the offers tie?
The recommendation uses a greater-than-or-equal test on the weighted values, so an exact tie goes to Offer A. In a test where both offers had identical inputs, each weighted value was $80,750.00 and Offer A was recommended.
Are the weights adjustable?
No. The $50 per PTO day, $500 per remote day per week, 235 working days and 2,080 hours are fixed in the code. If they do not match how you value your time, treat the true compensation lines as your main comparison and weigh PTO and remote days yourself.
What does the tool leave out?
Taxes, health insurance, retirement matching, equity, job security and growth prospects are all outside the calculation, as is the cost of living in each location. For benefits such as insurance and retirement matching, the job offer value calculator covers those inputs. This tool is a financial lens, not a verdict.
How does it treat invalid or blank inputs?
A cleared entry counts as 0, and negative entries are raised to 0. Remote days are capped at 5 per week. There is no check that a salary of 0 makes sense, but a zero salary gives a zero hourly equivalent and so a zero commute time value.
Comparing two job offers: commute time, PTO and remote days in dollars
What the tool puts a price on
Four things are converted to dollars. Pay is salary plus bonus. Commuting has an out-of-pocket cost you enter and a time cost the tool calculates from your hourly equivalent. PTO days and remote days a week carry fixed values for the recommendation only. The result is a pair of true compensation figures, a pair of weighted values and a recommendation for the higher weighted one.
Worked example: the default offers
Offer A pays $70,000 plus $5,000 with $2,400 of commute cost and a one-hour round trip, giving net compensation of $72,600.00. Commute time over 235 days values at $7,908.65, so its true compensation is $64,691.35. Offer B pays $65,000 plus $8,000 with $600 of commute cost, a 0.25-hour round trip and 3 remote days, for net compensation of $72,400.00 and true compensation of $71,665.63. After the PTO and remote weights, the weighted values are $65,441.35 and $74,165.63, so Offer B is recommended.
How remote days change the answer
The table reruns the default Offer B with and without its 3 remote days and adds two other comparisons. The second row isolates the effect of remote days alone: removing them raises the commute hours Offer B must value, and removes the remote weight.
| Case | Offer A true comp | Offer B true comp | Offer A weighted | Offer B weighted | Recommended |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Default inputs | $64,691.35 | $71,665.63 | $65,441.35 | $74,165.63 | Offer B |
| Default, but Offer B has 0 remote days | $64,691.35 | $70,564.06 | $65,441.35 | $71,564.06 | Offer B |
| A: $90,000, no bonus, 1.5 h commute, $3,600 cost, 10 PTO. B: $80,000, no bonus, fully remote, 25 PTO | $71,147.60 | $80,000.00 | $71,647.60 | $83,750.00 | Offer B |
Worked example: a higher salary against a remote job
Offer A pays $90,000 with a 1.5-hour round trip, $3,600 of commute cost and 10 PTO days. Offer B pays $80,000, is fully remote and has 25 PTO days. Offer A’s net compensation of $86,400.00 falls to $71,147.60 once the time spent commuting is valued, while Offer B stays at $80,000.00. The $10,000 salary gap more than disappears, and Offer B is recommended.
Limits worth remembering
The weights are the tool’s own and reflect one way of valuing time, not market data. Use the results to test how sensitive the choice is to commute and remote working, and add the things the tool leaves out, such as insurance, retirement matching and growth prospects, before deciding.
Learn more from an authoritative source:
U.S. Bureau of Labor StatisticsFreelance Rate Calculator
Calculate the minimum viable freelance hourly rate to match or exceed a target salaried income.
Remote Work Savings Calculator
Calculate money and time saved by working from home versus commuting to the office.
Job Offer Value Calculator
Compare two job offers on total compensation including salary, bonus, benefits, retirement match, and PTO.
Career Gap Cost Calculator
Estimate the total financial cost of a career break including lost salary, retirement contributions, and career trajectory.
Payslip Calculator
Get a full payslip breakdown showing every deduction line — income tax, NI/PF/social security, pension, and net pay — for your gross monthly salary.
LinkedIn Bio Generator
Generate a compelling LinkedIn summary (About section) that showcases your expertise and attracts the right opportunities.
Results are estimates for informational purposes only and do not constitute professional financial, medical, legal, or technical advice. Read full disclaimer →